Wednesday, October 3, 2012

Great Work, Readers!

Hey, reading crew!  Nice work responding to the question.  I look forward to hearing the rest of the class's comments as well.  If you have a chance to respond to the following question, I'd love to hear it!

What did you think of "Lob's Girl"?  Were you surprised by the ending, or did you see it coming?  What was your favorite part of the story, or did you have any connections to it?

Have a great day tomorrow, and be good for Mr. Pike. :)

Mrs. E. 

33 comments:

  1. Yes I was surpised at the ending because Sandy got hit by a van and the same van that Lob was hit by.I did not have any connections to the story.

    ~Goober

    ReplyDelete
  2. I was very surprised at the ending of the story!! But at the same time I was relly confused but after I read it again I figured it out. My favorite part of the story was when Lob traveled so far just to be with Sandy. I acn connect to this story because a couple of weeks ago one of my dogs died and like 4 years agho another one of our dogs died when it got hit ny a car and the person who hit hime did not care at all.:(
    Soph

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sorry I forgot to spell check!! On line 5 acn should be can!:)
      Soph

      Delete
    2. Hey Soph,
      My friend Mackenzie. Had a cat named Dora. Dora got hit by a car & died. The preson that hit her did not care that he/she hit the cat :(. My step sister Jessica. Has a cat named Pumkin. He got hit by a car but he is still alive, but hurt really bad. That person did not care he/she hit the cat :(.
      ~Goober
      P.S- Line 10 you put hime in sted of him.:) You are welcome for telling you for a spelling air.

      Delete
    3. Sorry. I fought his name is Peanut.
      ~Goober

      Delete
    4. Hi Goober,
      Thank you for responding and thats sad that that your friend Mackenzie's cat died and that your step sisters cat is really hurt. :(
      Soph
      P.S. Thanks for telling me about the spelling error!:)

      Delete
    5. that was my favorite part to soph!!

      Delete
    6. Hey Bugsy what is your favorite book you have ever read?

      Delete
    7. Hey Soph what is your favorite book ?

      Delete
    8. Hey Shay Dog,
      My favorite book is the Hunger Games Series but I also like Hatchet and 13 Gifts.
      Soph

      Delete
    9. My favorite books are the Hunger Games Trilogy but I also like Hatchet and 13 Gifts.
      Soph

      Delete
    10. Oh sorry I submitted it twice!
      soph

      Delete
  3. I don't think Lob really died. I think it was diffrent dog. Becaus it said that Lob had a round peace of cement on his callar. It was still verry sad.
    I only had one connection to it with a little twist. Last year my dog ( used to be Jade's Grandma's dog) ran away. She ran all the way to the highway. We found out in one eye that she's blind but she's OK! :)
    -CloCho

    ReplyDelete
  4. I wasn't suprised at the ending because I had read many stories about animals and almost always the abimal died at the end of the story. I can kind of connect to the story because my really old cat Skeeter died a year ago, and I have another cat who really loves me ( he actually can't sleep unless he has me with him and my old blanket)

    - Renderer

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hey Renderer,
      My friend Mackenzie had 2 cats die. One was hit by a car. That one is Dora. The 2nd one was sick when she was born. That one was Boots.
      ~Goober

      Delete
  5. I think that I saw it coming at the end but I thought it was really sad I startd to cry as i was reading it I can sord of realate to it because my horse chasey got hit by a big truck and my dad had to put her down when I was real little and after she died her mom died from old age and we had only one hores left named A.C that was the brother of Chasey he was very lonley we still have him though but he is not lonley any more he he has freinds now.Shay Dog

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. WOW! I did'nt know that happend to you that so sad!
      -CloCho

      Delete
    2. Ya it was it was really funny because she was still really young and my dad was still working on training her and when ever he would hop on her to ride she would take off flying and once he smacked his face on a tree when she took of I started to ball becaus I thought he was hert and I was really little.
      -Shay Dog

      Delete
    3. Hey Shay Dog,
      I never knew you had a horse named Chasey!
      Thats really sad that it got hit by a truck.:( But one of our dogs named Emitt got hit by a car too and we had to put him down.
      Soph

      Delete
    4. hey shay dog i never knew either!!
      i agree with soph and i never knew Emitt soph!

      Delete
    5. Hey Bugsy,
      Ya Emitt got hit by a car and died about 4 or 5 years ago.:(
      Soph

      Delete
    6. Hey soph I never new that you had a dog named Emitt what typ of dog was it

      Delete
    7. Hey Bugsy what typ of truk hit your cat?

      Delete
    8. IT WAS A UPS TRUCK AND NOW WHEN I SEE ONE I GET MAD!!!!!!
      I was very sad and one time one little cat we had got in the grage we my mom was driving in and my mom accidently ran it over! :(

      Delete
    9. Hey Shay Dog,
      Emitt was a yallow lab he was about 1 year old when he died.:(
      Soph

      Delete
    10. O Soph I think I remember seeing a picture of Emitt and your dad at your house.

      Delete
    11. Hey Bugsy I didn't know that your mom acsedentlye ran your cat over

      Delete
  6. i was very supprised but then i thought about it and they didnt say any thing about lob when sandy got hit it made sence. but i cant believe lob came back from the dead!

    ReplyDelete
  7. i was very suprised when the got hit by the van. i didnt have and connections wit the story
    -mmm

    ReplyDelete
  8. i was surprised that lob died and it was sad becaus he walked the whole of england twice and toataly loved sandy and i am sure he was missing his original owner........................................................................te

    ReplyDelete
  9. i was suprised when lob died and very sad but part of me thought he was still alive.I was kinda confused when his spirit or whatever it was came back even after i read it 3 times! I don't like how sad it was.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I was very surprised at the ending of this book. I thought something bad would happen but not that bad.

    I was very surprised when Lob came back fom his home to see Sandy twice.

    (I love blogging and I hope we have more conversations, bye:)

    ReplyDelete
  11. i loved it!!! but i did not like the ending.it was too sad:( but it was very sweet:)

    pinkpanda

    ReplyDelete